MITCHELL — The post-judgment battle in between the Corn Palace Stampede and owner Horsemen’s Sports Inc. continues with CPS alleging that HSI is attempting to hold the July rodeo on the identical dates CPS had planned to till it canceled earlier this year. of the month.

On May perhaps 18, CPS filed a court short searching for an injunction against HSI to enjoin the lessor from holding a rodeo or “any other competitors or spectator occasion or in any way disturbing the home (CPS) awarded by the jury for a period of 150 days.”

It also requests that HSI be prohibited from working with names or promoting events such as “Corn Palace Stampede,” “Corn Palace Rodeo,” “Corn Palace Rodeo,” “Stamped Rodeo,” or “Mitchell Rodeo,” or any other name that would recommend that it is related with the Corn Palace Stampede or any other rodeo-sort occasion traditionally held in Mitchell. The injunction request also seeks to prohibit HSI from searching for sponsorship for any rodeo events from CPS sponsors.

In an affidavit, CPS Board President Jim Miskimmins mentioned, “HSI is attempting to hold itself up like the Corn Palace Stampede Rodeo, and use CPS home to hold the rodeo in spot of the rodeo that CPS has canceled.

“These negotiations failed simply because of HSI’s really unreasonable terms,” ​​he wrote. “CPS has explored other selections for holding the rodeo in 2023, but none are viable offered the time constraints and logistical challenges of moving our grandstands and other assets from HSI’s rodeo grounds.” It is estimated that the price of renting the components and gear important to host the rodeo at an additional place will exceed $one hundred,000.

In an additional affidavit, Jimmie Nicolaus, who has been a member of CPS for a lot more than 30 years, wrote that he was contacted by a buddy who mentioned his son had been contacted to be the rodeo announcer for the third weekend in July occasion. Nikolaus mentioned the identical buddy was contacted about the Mitchell Rodeo trial.

“I am concerned that, offered HSI’s history of damaging CPS home, HSI will harm the products the jury awarded to CPS if it holds the rodeo,” Nikolaus wrote.

The subsequent hearing in the case is scheduled for June 9.

Earlier in the month, CPS requested a 150-day injunction to enable him to take away his home from the Horseman grounds. In response to the second injunction request, HSI lawyer Tim Whalen known as it “a lot more cautious than the initial” and known as the 150-day relocation request a “ransom maneuver.”

“The conduct (CPS) seeks to enjoin by HSI has never ever been pleaded or litigated in any respect and is totally novel,” he wrote. “Additionally, the actions (CPS) sought to enjoin have been never ever threatened, pointed out or otherwise alleged by HSI.” The action restricted by the prohibition can not be speculative or imaginary.”

Whalen argued that the ball is back in CPS’s court, specially considering the fact that the lease in between the two was terminated in court and CPS was awarded monetary damages and received its share of the home.

“The parties are now in a position to go their separate approaches.” (CPS), on the other hand, continues to seek to bond with HSI. If (CPS) does not want HSI to use its home, the resolution is basic — take away the home from HSI’s land,” he wrote.

Whalen also argued that HSI currently had the capability to use the home for its rodeo events and that the prior lease did not give CPS exclusive use or manage of the home, and that the court could not build new rights for CPS that would additional limit HSI’s use. home.

“The thought that (CPS) can restrict the use of names related with the city of Mitchell, the effectively-recognized Corn Palace or the term ‘rodeo’ in any respect is really arrogant and fully unsupported by any of the information right here or the law.” … Additionally, there are no non-compete or non-use agreements in between the parties to this action. … “HSI remains entitled below the law to use its assets as it sees match.”

Whalen also charged that CPS could not avert HSI from reaching business enterprise agreements with earlier CPS sponsors due to the identical lack of current non-compete agreements.

“The prosecutor’s boldness in this regard is unbelievable,” he wrote. “The plaintiff has no partnership with any firm or entity that is exclusive.”

In court in April, HSI President Brandon Nouegauer testified that HSI was interested in holding a lot more rodeo events at the grounds in the future and had been approached by youth, higher college and South Dakota Rodeo Association circles, along with a certain bull riding occasion. . He mentioned HSI will use the whole facility in these circumstances.

In the April case, a jury ruled that CPS could take key components of the rodeo grounds with it to the new facility, plus award CPS $one hundred,000 in damages just after ruling that HSI breached its contract with CPS. The lawsuit was sparked in 2020 when HSI members moved fences and tore up VIP platforms constructed by CPS as portion of an arena expansion. CPS then accused HSI of breaching the lease and argued that the improvements it had paid for have been private home and could be moved to a new place close to Mitchell Regional Airport.

CPS announced on May perhaps eight that it is canceling the rodeo, but will nonetheless have its conventional Saturday morning parade and Sunday’s kids’ entertaining day and chili cook-off at a new place close to the airport the weekend of July 15-16.

The Equestrian Sports Arena, positioned on State Highway 37 close to Lake Mitchell, is the only place exactly where the Corn Palace Stampede Rodeo has ever been positioned, dating back to 1971. Considering the fact that the dispute started, the Corn Palace Stampede has designed an additional organization, the Mitchell Rodeo Foundation, and agreed lease in 2021 to use 20 acres of land close to the airport for a future rodeo.

By Editor

Leave a Reply